“A second pet can work well, but it depends on temperament, environment and how carefully the introduction is managed.”
Mon / Fri 7:30 am - 7 pm | Sat 9 am - 4 pm
It would be wonderful to be surrounded by loads of pets – at least I think so! However, most of us start with one and then go from there.
One of the most common questions I get is “Should we get another pet?”
The quick answer is: if it is at all possible, then yes, definitely get another pet.
Having two pets under the right circumstances can be very rewarding for the pets and the whole family, contributing to a warm, happy environment (most of the time!).
But there are some things to consider first, including species (cat, dog, or other), breed, temperament, space available, available time, and finances, to name a few.
I think that most people fear how their current pet will react, and this is a valid concern. With cats, though we have domesticated and conditioned them (at least we like to believe!), they are generally solitary animals and bringing in a second cat or kitten can disturb the status quo and greatly upset the established cat.
In most circumstances, the temperament of the cat is the most important thing, as some will just not tolerate a new brother or sister at all, and so it shouldn’t be attempted in the first place. However, in many circumstances, I think a new cat can be introduced into a household as long as it is done slowly and with supervision. Also, I think introducing a kitten has a higher chance of success, since the adult will usually be less threatened.
With dogs, the story is a little different, as, on the whole, they are a more welcoming species and more accustomed to a larger pack environment. Of course, as with cats, this does depend on the personality of the first dog, and if they don’t get on with other dogs, then it shouldn’t be attempted.
But in most cases, a new dog can be introduced, and again, even better if it is a puppy. With the introduction of a second younger dog or puppy, some older dogs get a new lease on life, which is lovely to see.
Always supervise the initial introductions and ensure you have control over both pets as they check each other out. Let them sniff each other, but if you feel that one seems to be getting upset, such as starting to snare, growl, hair pricking up, ears back, then pull them away and start again when they’ve settled.
If one rolls onto their back, this usually indicates submissive behaviour, which is not a bad thing, as this kind of behaviour usually averts aggression. So don’t intervene. It is important to let them display acceptable natural behaviour, but not to tolerate aggression. If you do this slowly and monitor for any problem cues, then there is a good chance they will become good friends.
With cats, it often takes quite a bit longer as many established cats’ noses will be out of joint with the introduction of a new family member. You can expect a lot of hissing and meowing, but monitor this in case it gets out of hand.
One of my clients has persevered with a lovely new female cat, but the older male just won’t have a bar of it, and sadly, it isn’t looking good. On the other hand, as you can see from the photo above, another of my clients has a lovely story of their new kitten becoming very close with their older, established cat, which has been great for both. A good product that may help with establishing a second cat is Feliway. This is a pheromone diffuser and can help to make the cats “feel good” and possibly reduce anxiety associated with the introduction.
“Adding another pet is not a reliable solution for anxiety or behavioural problems and can sometimes make them worse.”
One thing to be careful of is considering a second pet when the first already has some anxiety behaviour, in the hope that it will settle down. This can be difficult and should be considered carefully.
If the anxiety is boredom-related, a carefully selected second pet and an appropriate introduction may help, though other techniques may be better. But with many anxieties, they need to be addressed primarily in the pet itself, using behaviour modification techniques and sometimes medications; relying on a second animal to help is likely to lead to further headaches.
One advantage of being a mobile vet is that I get to see the environment in people’s homes, which can help assess whether it is suitable for a second pet, and we can also have a good discussion about the pros and cons.
With the appropriate measures in place in many circumstances, a second pet can be welcomed into the home. To arrange a house call to chat about how to introduce a new pet, call me
Key Takeaways
- A second pet can be rewarding, but only under the right conditions
Success depends on temperament, environment and how introductions are managed. - Cats and dogs respond differently to new animals
Dogs are often more adaptable, while cats may take longer to adjust. - Introducing pets slowly and under supervision is essential
Careful observation helps prevent stress and reduces the risk of conflict. - A second pet is not a solution for behavioural problems
Underlying anxiety or behavioural issues should be addressed directly.
In-Home Services
In-home care forms the foundation of how we treat and manage your pet’s health. Most conditions can be assessed, treated, and monitored in a familiar environment where pets are calmer and easier to handle. Available to residents of Sydney’s inner city, Inner West, Eastern Suburbs and the Lower North Shore.
Testimonials
Debby Ross
First visit from Ari and Ellie and it went beyond all expectations. They were so genuinely interested in my two cats. Of course I couldn’t stop talking about them but they clearly were not bored. Did excellent health checks and vaccinations – was an absolute pleasure and I would totally recommend them to anybody. So fabulous having no stress of lugging…
Daniel Birchall
Elle’s exceptionally professional, warm, and helpful phone manner, together with Dr Ari’s prompt arrival, gentle approach with Hudson, and clear, thorough medical explanations and recommendations, immediately put my mind at ease. The high level of care and professionalism demonstrated confirmed that contacting VETaround was the right decision.
Amanda Yeates
Ari is the best vet ever. His home visits are incredible. Such a great service to not have to put your beloved pets in the stressful situation of a car. Or around sick pets in a waiting area. My cats LOVE HIM. Ollie my male cat NEVER comes out of hiding when visitors come over. With Ari, he not only came out, let him weigh him, have his check up done…
Charmaine Caffrey
I was very pleased with the ladies from VETaround Mobile vet. Professional, polite and very knowledgeable. Certainly eased my mind about my cat 🐈 would recommend them to anyone needing good veterinary care for their pet. We all know just how important our four legged friends are!
Frequently Asked Questions
Is getting a second pet a good idea for my household?
A second pet can be a positive addition if your current pet’s temperament and your environment support it. Factors like time, space, finances and compatibility all need to be considered. The decision should be based on whether both pets can adjust safely and comfortably.
How do I know if my current pet will accept another animal?
Temperament is the most important factor. Some pets are naturally more tolerant, while others may struggle with sharing their space. Careful observation of how your pet reacts to other animals can help guide your decision.
What is the safest way to introduce two pets to each other?
Introductions should be gradual and always supervised. Allow the animals to observe and sniff each other while maintaining control, stepping in if signs of stress or aggression appear. Taking things slowly gives both pets time to adjust.
Are cats harder to introduce to new pets than dogs?
Cats are generally more territorial and can be slower to accept a new animal. It is common to see hissing or withdrawal during the early stages. With patience and gradual introductions, some cats will adjust, but not all will tolerate a new companion.
Can getting a second pet help with my pet’s anxiety or boredom?
In some cases, a second pet may help if boredom is the main issue. However, many behavioural problems need to be addressed directly through training or management. Relying on another animal alone can lead to more complications.
How can a mobile vet help when considering a second pet?
A mobile vet can assess your pet in their home environment and identify factors that may affect how a new pet is introduced. This includes observing behaviour, space and routine. Advice can then be tailored to your specific household.